| A-1 | Ed Belfour / Rod Gilbert / Carey Price / Cam Neely / Rob Blake / Michel Goulet / Igor Larionov / Zdeno CharaAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-2 | Martin Brodeur / Nicklas Lidstrom / Jaromír Jágr / Sidney Crosby / Steve Yzerman / Alexander Ovechkin / Terry Sawchuk / Raymond BourqueAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-3 | Sergei Fedorov / Bryan Trottier / Chris Chelios / Frank Mahovlich / Tim Horton / Ron Francis / Ted Lindsay / Peter StastnyAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-4 | Glenn Hall / Borje Salming / Chris Pronger / Scott Stevens / Brad Park / Gilbert Perreault / Luc Robitaille / Eric LindrosAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-5 | Dominik Hasek / Larry Robinson / Teemu Selanne / Joe Sakic / Brett Hull / Peter Forsberg / Jari Kurri / Bobby ClarkeAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-6 | Gordie Howe / Mario Lemieux / Maurice Richard / Bobby Hull / Jean Béliveau / Guy Lafleur / Mark Messier / Doug HarveyAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-7 | Jarome Iginla / Gerry Cheevers / Grant Fuhr / Dale Hawerchuk / Denis Savard / Tony Esposito / Pat LaFontaine / Mike ModanoAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-8 | Patrick Kane / Brian Leetch / Bernie Parent / Pavel Bure / Pavel Datsyuk / Scott Niedermayer / Al MacInnis / Mats SundinAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-9 | Paul Kariya / Doug Gilmour / Henrik Lundqvist / Phil Housley / Alex Delvecchio / Bob Gainey / Darryl Sittler / Billy SmithAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-10 | Jacques Plante / Mike Bossy / Stan Mikita / Denis Potvin / Phil Esposito / Paul Coffey / Marcel Dionne / Ken DrydenAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-11 | Jean Ratelle / Adam Oates / Brendan Shanahan / Yvan Cournoyer / Mike Gartner / Joe Thornton / Johnny Bucyk / Joe NieuwendykAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| A-12 | Henrik Zetterberg / Marc-André Fleury / Dino Ciccarelli / Jonathan Toews / Larry Murphy / Curtis Joseph / Jeremy Roenick / Steve ShuttAll Time Draft | All Time Draft | |
| BB-1 | Bobby Clarke / Bill BarberBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-2 | Bobby Clarke / Dave SchultzBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-3 | Clark Gillies / Denis PotvinBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-4 | Denis Potvin / Billy SmithBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-5 | Frank Mahovlich / Dick DuffBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-6 | Glenn Anderson / Jari KurriBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-7 | Gordie Howe / Alex DelvecchioBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-8 | Grant Fuhr / Paul CoffeyBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-9 | Guy Lafleur / Pete MahovlichBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-10 | Guy Lafleur / Scotty BowmanBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-11 | Jaromír Jágr / Kevin StevensBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-12 | Larry Robinson / Serge SavardBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-13 | Mario Lemieux / Jaromír JágrBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-14 | Mario Lemieux / Larry MurphyBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-15 | Mark Messier / Jari KurriBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-16 | Mike Bossy / Denis PotvinBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-17 | Steve Shutt / Larry RobinsonBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| BB-18 | Steve Shutt / Pete MahovlichBack to Back | Back to Back | |
| C-1 | Bill GadsbyCaptains | Captains | |
| C-2 | Chris CheliosCaptains | Captains | |
| C-3 | Dale HawerchukCaptains | Captains | |
| C-4 | Dit ClapperCaptains | Captains | |
| C-5 | Eddie ShoreCaptains | Captains | |
| C-6 | Jarome IginlaCaptains | Captains | |
| C-7 | Joe SakicCaptains | Captains | |
| C-8 | Joe ThorntonCaptains | Captains | |
| C-9 | Mike ModanoCaptains | Captains | |
| C-10 | Nels StewartCaptains | Captains | |
| C-11 | Pat LaFontaineCaptains | Captains | |
| C-12 | Paul KariyaCaptains | Captains | |
| C-13 | Raymond BourqueCaptains | Captains | |
| C-14 | Stan MikitaCaptains | Captains | |
| C-15 | Teemu SelanneCaptains | Captains | |
| E-1 | Dominik Hasek / Peter ForsbergEnshrined | Enshrined | |
| E-2 | Ed Belfour / Doug GilmourEnshrined | Enshrined | |
| E-3 | Grant Fuhr / Pat LaFontaineEnshrined | Enshrined | |
| E-4 | Joe Mullen / Denis SavardEnshrined | Enshrined | |
| E-5 | Joe Sakic / Mats SundinEnshrined | Enshrined | |